agridat (version 1.8.1)

harris.multi.uniformity: Multi-year uniformity trials with different crops at Huntley

Description

Multi-year uniformity trials with different crops at Huntley

source

Harris, J Arthur and Scofield, CS. (1920). Permanence of differences in the plats of an experimental field. Jour. Agr. Res, 20, 335-356. http://naldc.nal.usda.gov/catalog/IND43966236 Harris, J Arthur and Scofield, CS. (1928). Further studies on the permanence of differences in the plots of an experimental field. Jour. Agr. Res, 36, 15--40. http://naldc.nal.usda.gov/catalog/IND43967538

Details

All yields are given in pound per plot, except sugar beets, which are given in tons per acre. Harris 1920: "In the spring of 1911 this field was laid out into 46 plots, each measuring 23.5 by 317 feet and containing 0.17 acre, arranged in two parallel series of 23 plots each. The two series of plots were separated merely by a temporary irrigation ditch. In 1911 it was planted to sugar beets, and in the spring of 1912 it was seeded to alfalfa, and one cutting was harvested that year. This stand remained on the ground during 1913 and 1914, when the entire field was fall-plowed. In 1913 three cuttings were made, but the third cutting was lost in a heavy wind which scattered and mixed the crop before weighings from the various plots could be made. The first cutting, designated as alfalfa I, was made on plots one-half the original size. The second cutting was harvested from plots one-quarter the original size. The first and second cuttings in 1914 were weighed for plots one-quarter the original size--that is, 0.0425-acre plots--while the third cutting was recorded for plots one-third the original size. These furnish the data for alfalfa I, II, and III for 1914. Total yields for the first and second cuttings in 1913 and 1914 and for the first, second, and third cuttings in 1914 are also considered. In 1915 and 1916 ear corn was grown. In 1917 the fields were planted to oats, and records were made of grain, straw, and total yield. In 1918 silage corn was grown. In 1919 the land produced a crop of barley." Harris 1928: "The southeast corner of Series II, the east series, is about 80 feet from the main canal, and the southwest corner of Series III is about 50 feet from Ouster Coulee. The main project canal carries normally during the irrigation season about 400 second-feet of water. The water surface in the canal is about 4 feet above the high corner of the field. It is evident from surface conditions, as well as from borings made between the canal and the field, that there is extensive seepage from the canal into the subsoil of the field. The volume of this seepage has been larger in recent years than it was in the earlier years of the cropping experiments, probably because the canal bank has been worn away by internal erosion, exposing a stratum of sandy subsoil that underlies the canal and part of the field. " "Whereas in the earlier crops Series II was better for alfalfa, Series III was better for alfalfa in the later period. The writers feel inclined to suggest that in the earlier experiments the height of the water table had no harmful effect upon a deep-rooted crop such as alfalfa. It is quite possible that during drier periods the higher water table actually favored alfalfa growth on Series II. The higher water tables of recent years have probably had a deleterious influence, which has been especially marked on Series II, where the water apparently comes nearer to the surface than in Series III."

Examples

dat <- harris.multi.uniformity
# Combine year/crop into 'harvest'
dat <- transform(dat, harv = factor(paste0(year,".",crop)))
# Convert 1911 from tons to pounds
dat$yield[dat$year==1911] <- 340 * dat$yield[dat$year==1911]

# Average yields. Harris 1928, table 2.
aggregate(yield~harv, dat, mean)

# Corrgram
require(reshape2)
mat <- acast(dat, series+plot~harv, value.var='yield')
if(require(corrgram)) corrgram(mat)
# Compare to Harris 1928, table 4.  More positive than negative correlations.
densityplot(as.vector(cor(mat)))

# Standardize yields for each year
mats <- scale(mat)
# Melt and re-name columns so we can make field maps.  Obvious spatial
# patterns that persist over years
d2 <- melt(mats)
names(d2) <- c('ord','harv','yield')
d2$series <- as.numeric(substring(d2$ord,1,1))
d2$plot <- as.numeric(substring(d2$ord,3))
# True field shape: aspect=.84 (536 ft North-South by 639 ft E-W)
# Series 2 is on the east side, so switch 2 and 3 for correct plotting
d2$xord <- 5 - dat$series
# Note that for alfalfa, higher-yielding plots in 1912-1914 were
# lower-yielding in 1922-1923.
desplot(yield ~ xord*plot|harv, data=d2, aspect=.84, flip=TRUE,
        main="harris.multi.uniformity")

# Crude fertility map by averaging across years shows probable
# sub-surface water effects
agg <- aggregate(yield ~ xord + plot, data=d2, mean)
desplot(yield ~ xord + plot, agg, main="harris.multi.uniformity fertility")